|
Note: This is a Text only archive. Go directly to the real forum.
Rate Superfan Roundtable: 1 to 10
- Click HERE to go to the original thread with graphics
banner
| Rate Superfan Roundtable: 1 to 10
- Click HERE to go to the original thread with graphics
|
| joetrumps |
I'd give it a 7
I think they waste a lot of time with unfunny shtick, but otherwise its pretty informative.
If the guests on the show were a bit more serious about answering the topic questions, and less about trying to do stand-up, the show would move much quicker. |
|
|
| otherone4life |
| 6-7 .. they talk over each other too much |
|
|
| Ruck Studabaker |
| 9 but a 10 if they asked me to be on :D |
|
|
| fahcue |
I havn't listened in about 20 weeks but judging from my previous experiences I would give it a 3 1/2 or 4.
I will listen to the next one to see what has changed. |
|
|
| moodmd |
| No survey? 10 and I look forward to it. |
|
|
| cheater6 |
5
Cut the number of panelists to Mutt and 3 guests....then they all wouldn't feel pressure to squeeze everything into 10 seconds |
|
|
| Lori |
Quote: Originally posted by joetrumps
I'd give it a 7
I think they waste a lot of time with unfunny shtick, but otherwise its pretty informative.
If the guests on the show were a bit more serious about answering the topic questions, and less about trying to do stand-up, the show would move much quicker. |
Shtick..really? I have never felt that. I think it's fans of the show expressing their opinions. No one's trying to be funny. I give it an 11. |
|
|
| BobbyDigital |
| 2 - don't really care for it. i don't need the show analyzed over and over again, it kills it for me (friday show, wrap up show, superfan show). |
|
|
| TONKA |
The show is well run, really fun to listen to and for the most part is filled with great insight and opinions from REAL fans.
The show moves really fast too.
I give it a 9. The thing that will bunp it up a notch would be getting some more production and allowing Mutt to utilize clips. This will make it a 10. |
|
|
| Gay Chef |
| They should change the show name to "How much can we kiss Joey Boot's ass in one hour Challenge" |
|
|
| italiafem |
| I really enjoy it b/c we also know the people from their screen names when they take part so it is cool to hear people off the board. Depending on who the guest is (i.e. Zolar, BB) that is when it can get out of control. Not the regulars. |
|
|
| breach |
9... its a great show....
they need to bump it up to be at least a 2 hour show |
|
|
| Robery |
| I give it a 6.. I think it is to short for all they want to talk about. I also think that there should be like mutt and maybe 1 or 2 others in the studio... |
|
|
| ICE CUBAN |
2
Between Ishtar sucky and Dennis Miller on MNF sucky |
|
|
| Jsteeler_7 |
| When Lori speaks it's a 10 :D |
|
|
| Morning Wood |
| i give it an 8 because whenever i get the chance, i still try to tune in. that's says a lot. |
|
|
| Lori |
Quote: Originally posted by Jsteeler_7
When Lori speaks it's a 10 :D |
Thanks baby! :) |
|
|
| Timmy |
| They should call it superregular-caller roundtable. |
|
|
| Zombie66 |
| I like it! I also think it would be cool if they expanded it to 2 hours. |
|
|
| jackelneck |
| SFRT is a solid 8.5 maybe 9.....it depends on the guests....when KOAB's is on 5....IMO |
|
|
| jrinck |
I love it, but sometimes I wonder if it's only because I interact with many of the panelists here.
Am I listening just because of SFN, or would I listen even if I had no idea what SFN was? I don't know how to answer that. |
|
|
| tnk |
| room for improvement..............9.5 :D |
|
|
| SoCalJeff |
| With the right guests I thinks its an 8. With the KOAB and his heavy breathing and ice chewing its a 3. The funny thing is I like KOABs when hes on the Stern Show. Hes funny as hell. But on SFRT, hes unlistenable. |
|
|
| tnk |
Quote: Originally posted by SoCalJeff
With the right guests I thinks its an 8. With the KOAB and his heavy breathing and ice chewing its a 3. The funny thing is I like KOABs when hes on the Stern Show. Hes funny as hell. But on SFRT, hes unlistenable. |
:bigclap: TRUE!!! |
|
|
| Artie's Bitch! |
Quote: Originally posted by breach
9... its a great show....
they need to bump it up to be at least a 2 hour show |
That's my vote too!!!!! |
|
|
| maloof |
Roundtable is by far one of the most honest shows, aside from THE SHOW, and the fans love it.
Just like the tagline........."of the fans, for the fans and by the fans......"
The Roundtable rules............A+++++++++++++++ |
|
|
| SHUA1973 |
I’m going to go with an 8. Can’t give it a 10 because then there would be no room for improvement. I think they defiantly need more time, or try to fit in less info and expand more on that.
At times they do talk over each other, but Mutt is usually pretty good at reeling them in quickly. |
|
|
| Mr Fister |
With King Of All Blacks- 0
With HPE- 0
With any other guests- 7 |
|
|
| socal_fun |
| I give it a 8. Mutt does a great job, I love Boots on there now. PLEASE don't have KOAB on there again though. Damm, can't handle that dudes voice. He's too loud and obnoxious!! |
|
|
| mikesbandit |
6
would be a little better with more attention to production, add stern bits, etc. maybe a longer show on the weekend??
the cheering and clapping have to stop, just really annoying. |
|
|
| WillowGlen |
6
It can be ground to a halt with the wrong guests. Zolar, Bobo etc. Bobo seems to use it as nothing more than a chance to see how many times he can sneak the F word on the air in one hour.
Mutt does a good job but he is too excitable and needs to lower his volume a smidge. As he gets more excited, the other people seem to try and out do him by being louder and talking faster. Then it just turns into a free for all with everyone screaming for 5 minutes until Mutt can rein them all back in. With the right guests it can be great. They just need to weed out the bad ones and find some interesting people. I think it also suffers from being on the day after the intern crapfest. Between those spoiled idiots and the wrap up show the current topics are pretty much run into the ground by the time they get a shot at them.
A webcam, (mainly pointed a Lori) might help.
And the song definetly has to go. |
|
|
| mrcutter |
| Sorry Lori...I really like you, but the show is pretty boring. Score: 2 |
|
|
| PUGS714 |
i have to give it a 9. great show !!!!!!!!!!
it still needs to be a longer show, the hour flys by and all the topics arte not coved each week. |
|
|
| petey5000 |
10
I wish it were 2 hours long |
|
|
| SkinnyV |
7
its ok for a free show, none of the guys will make $ on it though |
|
|
| strange1 |
Concept - 7-8
Execution - 5 Needs more creative thought. More original opinions. My suggestion would be for the fans to contribute some original material (stuff that never gets accepted on the show), and not just review the show. Boots has a forum to start showing off his comedic genius. We all have, more or less, the same taste in entertainment and there are some sfnrs who are frickin hilarious. |
|
|
| Juicy Princess |
Quote: Originally posted by Deryk
1 |
:rolleyes: |
|
|
| scabies |
| Haven't listened to it enough to give it an honest score. |
|
|
| strange1 |
Quote: Originally posted by WillowGlen
6
It can be ground to a halt with the wrong guests. Zolar, Bobo etc.
I think it also suffers from being on the day after the intern crapfest. Between those spoiled idiots and the wrap up show the current topics are pretty much run into the ground by the time they get a shot at them.
And the song definetly has to go. |
Thoughts worth heeding. Show needs a producer. Joey, this is your chance to step up. Let's see what you got.
Song definitely goofy. The Friday Show song needs to die yesterday. Friday, friday, friday, friday ..... AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
|
|
| Black Sabbath |
| I think it seens too rushed! They need more time! |
|
|
| JoeyBoots |
Quote: Originally posted by Gay Chef
-6 |
Quote: Originally posted by Gay Chef
They should change the show name to "How much can we kiss Joey Boot's ass in one hour Challenge" |
NOT GONNA LET YOU INSULT ME ANYMORE DOUCHEBAG.....YOU HAVE HAD AN AGENDA ON THIS BOARD WHEN IT COMES TO ME AND i JUST PUT A STOP TO YOU AND IT.........GOOD DAY SIR......oops caps.....sorry. :hw:
Gay Chef
dead account |
|
|
| Nursegrrl8 |
I think we take for granted how accepted fans are since the move to Sirius.
Could you imagine ANYTHING like this show even one year ago? Fantatstic.
I am fascinated by it. The fact that they give the fans a forum to voice their opinions AND actually read SFN openly - still phases me. :) |
|
|
| hattrick |
1 to 10 using what formula? :rolleyes:
This is a one-and-only original project: Sirius sponsored, hailed by Howard Stern, endorsed by The Show, pioneered by Mutt and spearheaded by SFNers :cool:
what are you comparing it to?
I give it a TEN (10) :btu: |
|
|
| JoeyBoots |
| I really feel like banning some more fuckers in this thread because i take their insults to be a bash on the owner of this board who happens to be the host of the show in question. |
|
|
| JoeyBoots |
| but i wont. :hw: |
|
|
| JoeyBoots |
| but like an elephant who returns to it's birthplace to die i never forget. :kw: |
|
|
| JoeyBoots |
Quote: Originally posted by strange1
............. Boots has a forum to start showing off his comedic genius. We ............. |
how's banning fuckers for comedy? |
|
|
| johnnyct8285 |
| i'll give it a 8, but if i was on it, it be an instant 10. HINT! HINT! |
|
|
| ants B list lvr |
| i really like the sfrt...i agree with howard that mutt is an exellent mc and everyone has great input ..i do agree that it needs to be expanded for another half hour so not so much rushing...i think it is the best thing on h 100-101 after the regular dj shows..i also really like miserable men.. :( |
|
|
| TheDomina |
I only had a chance to listen to it once, but I enjoyed it.
Mutt has alot of energy and a good radio voice.
The song could go though. |
|
|
| debfan |
| I give it a 10. Always a great show!!!!! Kudos to Mutt. He does a great job. |
|
|
| PETROCK |
Quote: Originally posted by JoeyBoots
but i wont. :hw: |
Come on now, you know it's fun....AND funny!!! :D |
|
|
| STEVEtheREALTOR |
| it's awsome I love the roundtable great show |
|
|
| JoeyBoots |
Quote: Originally posted by PETROCK
Come on now, you know it's fun....AND funny!!! :D |
ok one more for good and funny measures.......the sacraficial noobie with 19 posts. :hw:
Quote: Originally posted by swampeast
1 |
swampeast
account on-hold |
|
|
| gpf590 |
| I enjoy the Roundtable, I'll give it a 9. Less talking over each other makes it a ten! |
|
|
| DaMan |
I like Mutt he has lot to offer and he is picking up with his radio career but to be honest the guests are sometimes ummm dumb. The dont know whwn to shut up and let the host of the show talk etc. there is some responsibilty involved with hosting the show so let him host it and speak when spoken to for the most part at least
5 = Show
8 = Mutt
3= Guests |
|
|
| MadMax |
Quote: Originally posted by Lori
Shtick..really? I have never felt that. I think it's fans of the show expressing their opinions. No one's trying to be funny. I give it an 11. |
Based on what I've seen I give you an 11 .
SFRT 9.0 |
|
|
| hhkr |
| I'd give it an 8. At times it seems to bog down a bit, but overall I find it quite interesting. |
|
|
| moodmd |
Quote: Originally posted by JoeyBoots
ok one more for good and funny measures.......the sacraficial noobie with 19 posts. :hw:
swampeast
account on-hold |
This shit is killing me. Nobody commenting. 
Good jobe with Gay Chef--tool. 
All noobs commenting strongly without taking time to acclimate too. Thank you JB |
|
|
| strange1 |
Quote: Originally posted by JoeyBoots
how's banning fuckers for comedy? |
Genius... |
|
|
| GayTony |
| 8...still developing but great concept and Mutt has come into his own...still some glitches but coming along very well. |
|
|
|
|
|
