The Official American Idol Top 24 Thread

Syesha was great. Good-bye Chikezie. Jason performance was just lazy.

So far yes...

The Jackson Report Edition - American Idol Top 10

It's top ten time and all I can say is that this is a top ten that has me just wondering how we got to this place, but okay here we go. Ryan's hair looks funny. Till Death stars in the front, make sure you catch that on camera. The year they were born is the theme and that's pretty rich.

Ramiele Malubay Alone - No surprise that she is a Karaoke Kid, she still sings like the karaoke kid. This song is a good and bad choice for her, because I feel that she won't rise to the occasion, but that remains to be seen. She needs to go home, but she has too much support from the Fillipa community. She is literally screaming at the top of her lungs. I don't care how sick she is and stop telling me she is sick. Sing or stay off the stage. Jackson Report: Right on the money Mister Jackson. No, he is not being too harsh, he is right on the money. Simon again is on the money, but she will only get by this week because of her cultural support.

Song Choice: 4 out of 10 Performance: 5 out of 10

Jason Castro Fragile - Another 1987 kid, what treat for us. This kid is annoying, he's lucky women like him. Parents who get kids toys that make noise need to be executed on the spot. The audience clapping is so off they just need to stop. His performance is pretty boring, man they need to stop clapping. This is not as bad as the first performance, but not that much better it was a muddy mess. Jackson Report: Alright nice and pleasant, but nothing special, sorta like your review Randy.

Song Choice: 3 out of 10 Performance: 5 out of 10

Syesha Mercado If I Were Your Woman - 1987 again, can we get away from this year and girl put away that baby cry, don't even like when kids do it. Not cute. This chick takes airhead to a whole new level. She is starting off promising, what happened to this woman she is proving she can sing. Beautiful, not flawless, but damned close, this girl is singing for her life and it shows. Chills and thrills time with Syesha. Jackson Report:Randy is on the money this is her best performance and he has every right to be shocked two weeks in a row she has stepped up.

Song Choice: 8 out of 10 Performance 9 out of 10

Jason and Ramiele so far are Bubble worthy and Syesha sailed through her performance, definitely stepped up her game.

Chikezie Eze If Only For One Night - He is a good performer, but his personality leaves much to be desired, I just don't like him. I respect his talent, but he is not as good as he thinks he is. His song selection has been bad, but his performances have saved him. After a weak start we are in his round house, bargain basement interpretations of Luther. Dude you ain't Luther and this performance is a step in the wrong direction. Song selection and performance are both off the mark tonight. Chikezie needs to go home, his attitude and talking back might put him on the bubble. Jackson Report: On the money Randy, Old School and a step in the wrong direction boring and uninspired. Randy and Simon got it right.

Song Selection: 5 out of 10 Performance: 6 out of 10

Brooke White Every Breath You Take - Singing the Police can turn into disaster or she will shine, let's see. She is the spitting image of her mother, two beautiful ladies. Brooke we have seen this before you have done this, give us more. Good, but will it be good enough. This is your standard run of the mill performance from Brooke. Her interpretation of the song is off as well, she just sang it, she never felt it. Jackson Report: Interesting song choice is an understatement. Right on the money again Mr. Jackson.

Song Choice: 3 out of 10 Performance: 6 out of 10

Why you taking the gloves off on Paula?

So you just noticed that now.

Brooke is good, should have stayed with just the piano.

duh?

I agree.

Hey BARNZ, I should have taken you on that bet about Syesha making the top ten.

Is Carly's husband the one with the tatoos all over his face ???

The Jackson Report Edition - American Idol Top 10

It's top ten time and all I can say is that this is a top ten that has me just wondering how we got to this place, but okay here we go. Ryan's hair looks funny. Till Death stars in the front, make sure you catch that on camera. The year they were born is the theme and that's pretty rich.

Ramiele Malubay Alone - No surprise that she is a Karaoke Kid, she still sings like the karaoke kid. This song is a good and bad choice for her, because I feel that she won't rise to the occasion, but that remains to be seen. She needs to go home, but she has too much support from the Fillipa community. She is literally screaming at the top of her lungs. I don't care how sick she is and stop telling me she is sick. Sing or stay off the stage. Jackson Report: Right on the money Mister Jackson. No, he is not being too harsh, he is right on the money. Simon again is on the money, but she will only get by this week because of her cultural support.

Song Choice: 4 out of 10 Performance: 5 out of 10

Jason Castro Fragile - Another 1987 kid, what treat for us. This kid is annoying, he's lucky women like him. Parents who get kids toys that make noise need to be executed on the spot. The audience clapping is so off they just need to stop. His performance is pretty boring, man they need to stop clapping. This is not as bad as the first performance, but not that much better it was a muddy mess. Jackson Report: Alright nice and pleasant, but nothing special, sorta like your review Randy.

Song Choice: 3 out of 10 Performance: 5 out of 10

Syesha Mercado If I Were Your Woman - 1987 again, can we get away from this year and girl put away that baby cry, don't even like when kids do it. Not cute. This chick takes airhead to a whole new level. She is starting off promising, what happened to this woman she is proving she can sing. Beautiful, not flawless, but damned close, this girl is singing for her life and it shows. Chills and thrills time with Syesha. Jackson Report:Randy is on the money this is her best performance and he has every right to be shocked two weeks in a row she has stepped up.

Song Choice: 8 out of 10 Performance 9 out of 10

Jason and Ramiele so far are Bubble worthy and Syesha sailed through her performance, definitely stepped up her game.

Chikezie Eze If Only For One Night - He is a good performer, but his personality leaves much to be desired, I just don't like him. I respect his talent, but he is not as good as he thinks he is. His song selection has been bad, but his performances have saved him. After a weak start we are in his round house, bargain basement interpretations of Luther. Dude you ain't Luther and this performance is a step in the wrong direction. Song selection and performance are both off the mark tonight. Chikezie needs to go home, his attitude and talking back might put him on the bubble. Jackson Report: On the money Randy, Old School and a step in the wrong direction boring and uninspired. Randy and Simon got it right.

Song Selection: 5 out of 10 Performance: 6 out of 10

Brooke White Every Breath You Take - Singing the Police can turn into disaster or she will shine, let's see. She is the spitting image of her mother, two beautiful ladies. Brooke we have seen this before you have done this, give us more. Good, but will it be good enough. This is your standard run of the mill performance from Brooke. Her interpretation of the song is off as well, she just sang it, she never felt it. Jackson Report: Interesting song choice is an understatement. Right on the money again Mr. Jackson.

Song Choice: 3 out of 10 Performance: 6 out of 10

Michael Johns We Will Rock You - 1978 cool we finally get to move out of 1987. The back stories are all a bit tiring at this point. Bad song choice right off the bat, not a good song for him to choose, it is a little better now, but it's all a little Karaoke at the moment, not feeling Michael at this moment, the vocals are all over the place. Folks you are not looking at a champion, this song has exposed him as just not all that. Hopefully not one will tell me that he's sick too. Jackson Report: Randy was influenced by the reaction of the audience and he lied.

Song Choice: 5 out of 10 Performance: 7 out of 10

All of the performances of this three are just not that good, but my bubble choices are in the first batch of three. Syesha had a better performance and more memorable performance than Michael.

Carly Smithson Total Eclipse Of The Heart - 1983, back to the eighties and bad song choice or obscure song choice and the whole back story is annoying. All of them are, give us less back story and a faster show. Get on with it already! This song is right in her range and ability, she will either rise to it or fall. The backup singer is a better vocalist than she is. Very karaoke and disappointing performance. I know you can sing, now thrill me, that performance never rose to the level of the potential. Jackson Report: Right on the money Randy, bad song choice and bad ending. Not a great performance. “The run at the end was not in tune Paula†Randy is stepping up his game and is getting it right.

Song Choice: 8 out of 10 Performance: 7 out of 10

I was posting in the wrong American Idol viewing thread.
I wondered where everyone was! I'm a tard

Here are couple of my thoughts I posted in the wrong thread...


Regarding Kristy Lee Cook's song choice:

She's sucking up to the "Git R Done" crowd.
Everyone get out your flags to wave!



What percentage of the time do you think Jason Castro is totally stoned?

He is adorable though.

i love to see stuff like this when a person steps up their game and they turn disbelievers into believers. Will never be a fan, but the lady proved herself.

Michael Johns was ok this week, nothing big.

Carly sing one of my favorite songs. She did a good job. Fuck Randy and Simon.

Kristy hasn't even sung yet, what are you talking about?

All the song choices have already made public by TMZ.
Someone mentioned it and I was responding with my opinion on the song she is going to sing.

The Jackson Report Edition - American Idol Top 10

It's top ten time and all I can say is that this is a top ten that has me just wondering how we got to this place, but okay here we go. Ryan's hair looks funny. Till Death stars in the front, make sure you catch that on camera. The year they were born is the theme and that's pretty rich.

Ramiele Malubay Alone - No surprise that she is a Karaoke Kid, she still sings like the karaoke kid. This song is a good and bad choice for her, because I feel that she won't rise to the occasion, but that remains to be seen. She needs to go home, but she has too much support from the Fillipa community. She is literally screaming at the top of her lungs. I don't care how sick she is and stop telling me she is sick. Sing or stay off the stage. Jackson Report: Right on the money Mister Jackson. No, he is not being too harsh, he is right on the money. Simon again is on the money, but she will only get by this week because of her cultural support.

Song Choice: 4 out of 10 Performance: 5 out of 10

Jason Castro Fragile - Another 1987 kid, what treat for us. This kid is annoying, he's lucky women like him. Parents who get kids toys that make noise need to be executed on the spot. The audience clapping is so off they just need to stop. His performance is pretty boring, man they need to stop clapping. This is not as bad as the first performance, but not that much better it was a muddy mess. Jackson Report: Alright nice and pleasant, but nothing special, sorta like your review Randy.

Song Choice: 3 out of 10 Performance: 5 out of 10

Syesha Mercado If I Were Your Woman - 1987 again, can we get away from this year and girl put away that baby cry, don't even like when kids do it. Not cute. This chick takes airhead to a whole new level. She is starting off promising, what happened to this woman she is proving she can sing. Beautiful, not flawless, but damned close, this girl is singing for her life and it shows. Chills and thrills time with Syesha. Jackson Report:Randy is on the money this is her best performance and he has every right to be shocked two weeks in a row she has stepped up.

Song Choice: 8 out of 10 Performance 9 out of 10

Jason and Ramiele so far are Bubble worthy and Syesha sailed through her performance, definitely stepped up her game.

Chikezie Eze If Only For One Night - He is a good performer, but his personality leaves much to be desired, I just don't like him. I respect his talent, but he is not as good as he thinks he is. His song selection has been bad, but his performances have saved him. After a weak start we are in his round house, bargain basement interpretations of Luther. Dude you ain't Luther and this performance is a step in the wrong direction. Song selection and performance are both off the mark tonight. Chikezie needs to go home, his attitude and talking back might put him on the bubble. Jackson Report: On the money Randy, Old School and a step in the wrong direction boring and uninspired. Randy and Simon got it right.

Song Selection: 5 out of 10 Performance: 6 out of 10

Brooke White Every Breath You Take - Singing the Police can turn into disaster or she will shine, let's see. She is the spitting image of her mother, two beautiful ladies. Brooke we have seen this before you have done this, give us more. Good, but will it be good enough. This is your standard run of the mill performance from Brooke. Her interpretation of the song is off as well, she just sang it, she never felt it. Jackson Report: Interesting song choice is an understatement. Right on the money again Mr. Jackson.

Song Choice: 3 out of 10 Performance: 6 out of 10

Michael Johns We Will Rock You - 1978 cool we finally get to move out of 1987. The back stories are all a bit tiring at this point. Bad song choice right off the bat, not a good song for him to choose, it is a little better now, but it's all a little Karaoke at the moment, not feeling Michael at this moment, the vocals are all over the place. Folks you are not looking at a champion, this song has exposed him as just not all that. Hopefully not one will tell me that he's sick too. Jackson Report: Randy was influenced by the reaction of the audience and he lied.

Song Choice: 5 out of 10 Performance: 7 out of 10

All of the performances of this three are just not that good, but my bubble choices are in the first batch of three. Syesha had a better performance and more memorable performance than Michael.

Carly Smithson Total Eclipse Of The Heart - 1983, back to the eighties and bad song choice or obscure song choice and the whole back story is annoying. All of them are, give us less back story and a faster show. Get on with it already! This song is right in her range and ability, she will either rise to it or fall. The backup singer is a better vocalist than she is. Very karaoke and disappointing performance. I know you can sing, now thrill me, that performance never rose to the level of the potential. Jackson Report: Right on the money Randy, bad song choice and bad ending. Not a great performance. “The run at the end was not in tune Paula†Randy is stepping up his game and is getting it right.

Song Choice: 8 out of 10 Performance: 7 out of 10

David Archeleta You're The Voice - 1990, cool, the audience is just totally annoying, let's see what he brings to the table. Controlled and good performance totally forgettable song, not feeling it. I know this song and I think he is doing a good job with a song that aims to be more than the sum of it's parts. Jackson Report: Check it our strange song choice indeed and he can sing, but overall a safe song choice.

Song Choice: 4 out of 10 Performance 7 out of 10

Paula said "David can sing the phone book"

Dam. David. What kind of song was that? he still safe.

Kristy next

TMZ.... Well i like not knowing before i hear it, but this chick needs to rise to the occasion and blow our, Socks off or she's going home.

I agree too. She sang good.